top of page
Search

Is it time to be less rigid about mixed-method analyses?

  • Writer: Sumedha Rajbanshi
    Sumedha Rajbanshi
  • Mar 31
  • 2 min read

As I have mentioned in my About me page, my background is in economics, which is thoroughly embedded in quantitative analysis. There isn't much qualitative analysis as understood by non-economics disciplines. One could make an educated guess that, quantitative data analysis will fail to incorporate a lot of pertinent qualitative considerations; conversely, qualitative analysis has severe limitations in the types of insights it can provide. Unfortunately, good quantitative analysis is time consuming. Especially when an analyst has to consider all the potential issues and concerns, it can take a few rounds of implementation to obtain the most accurate estimates.


While I am marginally less experienced in qualitative analysis, I do not find it to be as time consuming or perhaps even as complex in comparison. It is not necessarily a bad thing, depending on the situation - after all, speed and rapid delivery (keeping quality fixed) is universally considered preferable.


Listening and reading the news about current debates, it hit me like a brick wall why there is so much demand for qualitative analysis. Currently, there are discussions about the harms of social media on mental health and life outcomes. The defense for social media is obviously going to make the claim that harmful effects do not exist; I have not read anything about the e.g. quantitative analysis conducted to reach such a conclusion, but it wouldn't surprise me that any quick calculation results in null effects. This is where qualitative analysis can be useful, because if e.g. court cases are on-going, decision makers require results now, which means qualitative analysis might be their only option (thus testimonies). Unfortunately, because they are taken as anecdotal evidence, they are considered less convincing compared to rigorous quantitative analysis using large datasets.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Yet another comment about AI

I have now written multiple posts about AI (AI and its ambitions, Another comment about AI), and unsurprisingly, people have changed their views about it. History has shown us overzealous beliefs abou

 
 
 
Aristocrats

At the end of King Charles and Queen Camilla's trip, DJT mentioned there should be more people like them in the United States. I had to chuckle at that. Why? Because of the entire history of this nati

 
 
 
When tax policy becomes too toxic

I already spoke about fiscal policies and the need for them in my earlier blog post (Fiscal policies), and thus taxation being one of the ways in which governments obtain revenue. It shouldn't come at

 
 
 

Comments


© 2035 by Autono. Powered and secured by Wix

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
bottom of page